NFL: Wednesday, I was sitting at the bar waiting for a friend to show up for dinner when I saw on Pardon the Interruption that the NFL is thinking of installing German microchip technology in footballs to help with goal line/first down calls. Michael Wilbon argued that the NFL needed to embrace the technology. He said that if there is technology to improve the product that sports should use it. I, wholeheartedly, agree. The NFL needs to make this change, and they need to make it soon. I remember in the 1996-1997 playoffs, the Eagles were playing the 49ers in the Wild Card round. During the game, which the Eagles lost 14-0, there was what looked like a sure first down taken from them when the officials placed the ball at an incorrect spot. In addition to the poor spot, it seemed that the referee tilted the marker to deny the Eagles a first down. While this could just be the clouded memory of a bitter fan, this scenario could not happen if the current technology existed at the time of the game.
Tennis already uses technology to help the chair umpires and lines people with in/out calls. The “Hawk-Eye” technology uses high-speed video cameras to capture the flight path of the ball and comes up with a composite picture of where the ball landed on the court. This has helped to eliminate some of the arguments, though not all, on calls during the match. FIFA has toyed with the idea of installing this technology on the goal line, which would have helped during this year’s World Cup when Frank Lampard scored against Germany but neither the referee or the assistant saw the goal. FIFA has also explored adding the chip technology to their soccer balls, but again has been slow to accept the new technology. I suspect that we may see changes soon due to the controversy generated following the World Cup. While the technology the NFL is looking at is not Hawk-Eye technology, the principle is the same: determine where the ball was at a given time and determine whether it crossed a line or not.
I am glad to see that the NFL is exploring the technology and I hope that FIFA and MLB will follow suit and embrace technology. Think of all the controversial calls in the last few months that could have been avoided. The Lampard “goal”. Armando Galarraga‘s “perfect game”. There was even a call in last night’s Phillies/Marlins game (Gaby Sanchez‘s “hit” that was called foul) that might have gone the other way if MLB used chip or even replay technology. Like Wilbon said, if there is technology to improve the product, use it!
MLB: The Red Sox found out yesterday that first baseman, Kevin Youkilis, will miss the rest of the season following thumb surgery. This is a huge blow for a team that is trying to make up 5.5 games in the standings over the final 2 months of the season. Going forward, I expect a platoon of Victor Martinez and Mike Lowell to cover the first base duties. Neither is as good defensively as Youk, and Lowell’s bat is a shadow of its former self. In addition, if Martinez plays first, somebody else will have to catch. With Varitek still on the DL, will we see newly acquired Jarrod Saltalamacchia called up?
This injury changes everything, as Youk has become the heart and soul of the line up. With his bat missing, and Dustin Pedroia “weeks” away from being activated, the Sox are missing a good deal of their power potential. While Adrian Beltre, David Ortiz, and Martinez are still in the line up, it has just become exponentially more difficult for the Sox to catch the Yankees and Rays. This weekend’s series with the Yankees takes on even greater importance with Youk out. The Sox have to hope that their rag-tag bunch of fill-ins can keep up their collective magic because the team can ill afford a poor series in the Bronx.